More data that challenges The Narrative
Repeat after me: New York City’s emergency rooms were not overwhelmed by visits in spring 2020. In fact, they were busier during the 2017-2018 flu season than they were at any point between lockdown orders and January 2022’s *omicron surge*.
Data from the New York City Department of Health & Hygiene, provided via FOIL request, tell a different story from the one told by elected officials, news media, dancing nurses, and aspiring celebrity doctors.
Contrary to The Narrative, Governor Cuomo’s stay-home orders didn’t come *just in time* to save NYC’s healthcare system from collapse. They triggered a staggering 60%+ decline in the number of people coming or being brought to ERs.1 That’s a hard truth to handle given the city’s record high number of EMS calls and hospital, outpatient facility, & ER deaths in spring 2020.
It’s likewise a hard, if predictable, truth to handle for those of us who were/are anti-lockdown.
- We remember how selected images of & video from NYC hospitals scaring people across the country about how dangerous covid must be.
- We remember being told, implicitly if not explicitly, that in order to avoid what was happening in New York, we must be content with Zoom church, screen school, carryout, & minimal in-person contact with humans outside our own household.
- We remember that anyone who questioned the wisdom of these directives – or wondered whether NYC hospitals were truly any busier than during a bad flu season – was a grandma killer. Meanwhile, grandma was being killed by the very policies & protocols put in place to *save hospitals* and *slow the spread,* not only in the hospital and at the long-term care facility, but also at home.2
No one denies thousands of New Yorkers died needlessly in March – May 2020. Now we know it wasn’t because the city’s ERs were overrun.
Republished by The Epoch Times and Brownstone Institute.
I’ll continue to pursue and publish data related to the NYC Spring 2020 Mortality Event, toward trying to help make sense of what happened, how, & why. Requests for and link to other relevant data welcome.
- NYC’s spring 2020 emergency visit decline was even greater than Chicago’s. ↩︎
- NYC deaths occurring at decedent’s home (all causes) ↩︎
10 February 2026: More recently, I’ve posited that a reason for the in-person ED visit drop were incentives for and encouragement to use telemedicine. See https://woodhouse76.com/2026/01/06/overdue-records-request-to-the-fire-department-of-new-york-fdny-for-telemedicine-calls-and-a-possible-reason-ed-visits-there-and-elsewhere-show-a-huge-drop/
Leave a Reply